NOTES ON THE ARGYLE AGREEMENT BETWEEN GUYANA  AND VENEZUELA.

DECEMBER 13, 2023.

By Dr. Abiola Inniss 

 

No. 8 of the agreement makes Ralph Gonsalves of St Vincent and the Grenadines ,  Rooseveldt Skerrit , and Brazil’s Ignacio Da Silva the substantive interlocutors in the border dispute and relegates the United Nations Secretary General to observer. NO MATTER WHO HOLDS THE OFFICE,it is the effective comptroller of the most powerful and effective internaional diplomatic organization in the world. The United Nations was created after the failed League of Nations following World War 2 for the purpose of instititionalizing diplomatic relations among nations.  

 Can these individuals who have temporary political office, and in the case of Gonsalves no real international diplomatic influence hold Venezuela to account? 

 

HOW IS THIS A WIN FOR GUYANA?    

  

This agreement weakens the diplomatic leverage that Guyana held one day ago and places Venezuela where it wants to be . It is now in a position through the new border commission to object to any developments of Essequibo in a formalised manner through interlocutors viv a vis the new border commission and to cause no end of problems for Guyana. 

 

Section 8 of the infamous Argyle agreement. 

 

8. Both States agreed that Prime Minister Ralph E. Gonsalves, the Pro-Tempore President of CELAC, Prime Minister Roosevelt Skerrit, the incumbent CARICOM Chairman, and President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva of Brazil will remain seized of the matter as Interlocutors and the UN Secretary-General, Antonio Guterres as Observer, with the ongoing concurrence of Presidents Irfaan Ali and Nicolas Maduro. For the avoidance of doubt, Prime Minister Gonsalves’ role will continue even after Saint Vincent and the Grenadines ceases to be the Pro-Tempore President of CELAC, within the framework of the CELAC Troika plus one; and Prime Minister Skerrit’s role will continue as a member of the CARICOM Bureau. 

  

Maduro tweeted earlier tonight that the agreement is a win for Venezuela and he may be right. Venezuela has not relinquished its claim on Essequibo and does not recognize the jurisdiction of the ICJ, but has managed to wheedle its way into Guyana’s affairs via CARICOM.  

 

The Argyle agreement will result in considerable troubles for Guyana unless it undergoes substantial revision. 

  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Alternative Dispute Resolution in the Caribbean: a cultural conundrum-Excerpts from a Guest lecture given at DePauw University, Indiana ,USA , 11/10/2011

Thank you for the opportunity of speaking to you on a subject that has been of great interest to me and of great importance to the peoples of the Caribbean region. I know that when many people think of the Caribbean, the immediate images of islands surrounded by sand and sea bathed in sunshine fun and frolic come to mind; that is what we see on TV By extension the exotic jungles of the South America in particular my native land Guyana , the only English speaking country on the continent of South America, may also capture the imagination as a paradise of the kind propagated in the movie Tarzan, very little is known about the cultural intricacies of the region in Western civilization outside of international organizations such as The United Nations and so the substantive issues of community life and conflict ,and of necessity conflict resolution make for a fascinating and important study. For the purpose of my discourse, I am confined to the fifteen countries which are members of Cari
Read more
The Guyana Government and the protection of Copyright laws. By Abiola Inniss         Recent weeks have found the Intellectual Property scene in Guyana astir with activity .According to reports the Guyana Government declared that as a matter of policy it would be spending millions of dollars to procure bootlegged British textbooks from an handful of local copy artists with large scale printing facilities. This bold declaration was made, it claimed, as a means of getting the most for the dollar and supposedly for the benefit of the nation. The Government made this declaration in the face of the existing Copyright Act of 1956 (Cap, 74) which states as follows: " In accordance with the preceding subsection, but subject to the following provisions of this Act, the copyright in a work is infringed by any person who, not being the owner of the copyright, and without the licence of the owner thereof, does or authorises another person to do, any of the said acts in relation to t
Read more

Applying Alternative Dispute Resolution Within Communities. -A speech presented at the Alternative dispute resolution forum of the United Nations Association of Guyana and the Guyana Association of Women Lawyers June 30 2010. rs

Applying Alternative Dispute Resolution Within Communities. By Abiola Inniss LLB, LLM (Business Law) ACIArb. In 1976 at the Pound Conference of the United States of America Supreme Court Chief Justice Warren Burger as he then was, on the subject of finding a better way declared ” We may well be on our way to a society overrun by hordes of lawyers, hungry as locusts, and brigades of judges in numbers never before contemplated. We have reached the point where our systems of justice—both state and federal—may literally break down before the end of the century .” This was a key point in advocating the use of ADR in the United States which was widely touted at the time as an alternative to the formal system of justice then in place. From the seventies to present there have been many projects implemented all across the United States with varying degrees of success from which valued lessons we may derive some wisdom on the subject of applying ADR in communities. We will also take a look
Read more